These individuals have put forth the time and intellectual ingenuity required to be known as an AMCS Club PUZZLE LEGEND!
| Spring 2006 |  Grant Adams and Joel Bernstein |
| Fall 2006 | Grant Adams |
| Spring 2005 | Grant Adams |
| Fall 2005 | Mike Miller |
| Spring 2004 | Mike Boldischar |
| Fall 2004 | Mike Miller |
| Spring 2003 | Marci Denil |
| Fall 2003 | Marci Denil |
| Spring 2002 | Nick Karpenske |