QUICK REFERENCE

PAGE 1
What is Reflection?

What is the purpose of reflection?

Where do you put the reflections in your portfolio?

What makes a good artifact?

What are the stages of a portfolio artifact?

Where will I find preservice and inservice artifacts?

PAGE 2
How to write a reflective statement

What makes a good reflective statement?

What is an excellent reflection?

Reflection as assessment?

How can you improve your written reflections?

How can you demonstrate and assess growth over time?

How can you assess your abilities to reflect?

PAGE 3
What kind of reflections should I have at benchmark I or at acceptance into the teacher education program?

What kind of reflections should I have at benchmark II or prior to student teaching or mid-program review?

What kind of reflections should I have at benchmark III or at program completion?

What do I do with all my reflections and artfacts at program completion at benchmark III?

Tips on organizing your exit portfolio (this is a link)

References

PAGE 1 | 2 | 3

For Preservice and Inservice Art Teachers
Authored by:
Sheri Klein, UW-Stout and William Chandler, UW-Whitewater

What is Reflection?

Integral to your production of a portfolio is the process of reflection. Reflection is not an 'add-on' piece to your learning process, portfolio, or teaching practice. It is integral to the complex process of becoming an art teacher. Successful reflection enables self-awareness, personal and professional growth and improved teaching practices.

Reflection may be accomplished individually and collectively. You will have opportunities to reflect on your experiences and teaching with others, such as, peers, cooperating teachers, supervisors and university faculty. Each will bring a unique perspective to your understanding of yourself as a developing art teacher.

Ultimately, self-reflection and dialogue with others will result in insights as to:

  1. how and why you think the way you do about art teaching, learning and assessment
  2. what actions you took, what choices you made
  3. the meaning of your actions and choices
  4. what learning and growth has occurred
  5. how you can change your practices in the future
  6. what you believe is the social value of art education
  7. what you believe is your role as a professional in the field of art education

What is the purpose of reflection?

You will be reflecting on the outcomes from your coursework and experiences.While reflection suggests recollection and the remembering of events and activities past, it is remembering with a grounding of beliefs. Dewey (1933) stated "reflection thus implies that something is believed in (or disbelieved in), not on its own direct account, but through something else which stands as witness, evidence, proof, voucher, warrant; that is, as ground of belief." (p.11). For Dewey, reflective thinking consisted of two parts: a state of doubt and a search to resolve that doubt. Thus, constructing a portfolio is an act of revealing one's beliefs. Schon (1988) considered a utility for reflective thinking in that cognitive practice has a direct relationship to practices within professional realms (teaching). Davis, Hawley, McMullan and Spilka (1997) extend this idea in that the process of education mirrors the design process with reflective thinking being central to both. Design as a process (Davis, et.al., 1997), like teaching art, requires critical reflection that can inform future events.

At the heart of portfolio development is purposeful choice making. The portfolio development process like the design process is organic.

Your portfolio can be entered into again and again with new reflections that can provide new insights.

Where do you put the reflections in your portfolio?

Your portfolio is an assessment portfolio. This means that it includes a collection of selected artifacts and focused reflections and goals that demonstrate how you have met the Wisconsin Teacher Standards and Wisconsin Model Academic Standards.

Reflections should be infused throughout your portfolio. One of the advantages of an E-Portfolio is the capacity to integrate text and images and to cross-reference using links.

What makes a good artifact?

The search for evidence in the form of artifacts is a quest for quality. The reflection process will assist you to determine how artifacts are collected, winnowed, and presented. Artifact selection requires that you place value upon an experience or event. As you develop your portfolio, you will be gathering 'artifacts' that demonstrate your competencies in each of the Standards 1-8. A good artifact is:

  • Carefully selected
  • Represents the standard
  • Demonstrates your competencies of the standard
  • Presented professionally
  • Personally meaningful
  • Paired with a relevant and insightful reflection (reflections can be written, audio or videotaped

For tips on inserting either image or video artifacts into your portfolio, click here.

What are the stages of a portfolio artifact?

Collection
Collect all relevant artifacts and store in a digital format. Make back up copies.

Selection
You should carefully select the artifact(s) that best exemplify how you have met the standard.

Reflection
Reflect on the artifact using 'How to Write A Reflection'. The artifacts should have personal meaning and significance to you.

Inclusion
Insert relevant reflections and artifacts in the portfolio.

Further Reflection and Assessment
Ask:
Do my current artifacts and reflections best demonstrate my competencies? What new artifacts do I have from this semester to add?

Further Editing and Selecting
Ask:

What artifacts and reflections should I remove? Do I have any artifacts and reflections to add that can demonstrate my growth over time?

Process adapted from: Barrett (2000) and Danielson & Abrutyn (1997). An introduction to using portfolios in the classroom. Alexandria, VA: ASCD. We have added the stages of Further Reflection and Assessment and Further Editing and Selecting.

FOR  PRESERVICE ART TEACHERS

Where will I find artifacts?

The following is a list of potential artifacts and their sources:

Context/Source
Artifact
Courses Classroom management philosophy
Philosophy statement
Essays
Curriculum plans
Peer critiques
Position papers
Research papers
Projects
Simulated experiences
Teacher-made materials
Transcripts
Video critiques
Visual art works


Field Experiences Assessment Plans
Curriculum plans and worksheets
Feedback from teachers
Goal statements
Field logs and journals
Interviews with students, parents, teachers
Class management plan
Notes from students and parents
Observation reports and evaluations
Photographs of students' works, classroom
Seating plans
Video of your teaching
Teaching using technology


Community and Professional Service Awards and certificates
Conference programs attended
Artifacts from volunteer and or community related employment or service


Sample Preservice Art Teacher Reflection

PAGE 1 | 2 | 3

FOR INSERVICE ART TEACHERS

Where will I find artifacts?
The following is a list of potential artifacts and sources:

Context/Source
Artifact
Graduate Courses and/or Professional Development Essays
Curriculum plans
Peer critiques
Position papers
Research papers
Projects
Simulated experiences
Teacher-made materials
Transcripts
Video critiques
Visual art works
Technology: CD's, websites, instructional materials


Your Classroom and Students Curriculum and assessment evidence
Feedback from students and parents
Photographs of students' works, classroom
Student reflections on their work and growth
Teacher reflection on students' works
Video of your teaching
Teaching using technology
Artifacts from classroom-based research


Community and Professional Service Awards and certificates
Artifacts from volunteer and or community related employment or service
Artifacts from service to professional organizations
Other forms of recognition for teaching, art work, etc.
Published journal articles about art teaching


Sample Inservice Art Teacher Reflection

PAGE 1 | 2 | 3

COPYRIGHT INFORMATION
Permission is granted to reproduce, store and/or distribute the materials appearing on this website with the following limits:
Materials on this website may not be modified, altered or edited in any way. Materials in this website may be reproduced, stored and/or distributed for information and educational purposes, and in no case for profit. This copyright page must be included and authors cited with any materials used from this site that are reproduced, stored and/or distributed © 2003 applies to this site and its content except where otherwise noted.
Website problems or question email kleins@uwstout.edu